24 March 2021
Brachycephalic anaesthesia – Part 1: The pre-anaesthetic period
This article, on Brachycephalic anaesthesia, intends to highlight the many complications that can arise during the pre-anaesthesic period with brachycephalic breeds, and address how to mitigate some of the risks. This first article will deal with the pre-anaesthetic stage discussing anatomy, admitting the brachycephalic patient and pre-anaesthetic checks, whilst a subsequent article will address the recovery period.
Being a member of the BVNA family means you have a free Veterinary Nursing Journal in the post every month, providing expert written content, and online access to all past issues with topic search facilities for easy research. Join us today to access all of our VNJ content!
Brachycephalic anaesthesia – Introduction
Brachycephalic dogs are continually gaining popularity and between 2016 and 2017 there was a 25% increase in brachycephalic breeds in the top 10 registered breeds with The Kennel Club (The Kennel Club, 2018).
A study conducted by Brodbelt et al. (2008) suggests that these breeds are at an increased risk of mortality associated with anaesthesia. However, a more recent study states that it is in fact the degree of brachycephalic status that has the highest impact on mortality of these patients (Gruenheld et al., 2018). The primary reason for this increased risk is Brachycephalic Obstructive Airway Syndrome (BOAS). BOAS is described as a combination of anatomical abnormalities within the upper respiratory tract which can cause obstruction of the upper airway and dyspnea (Adshead, 2014).
Understanding brachycephalic-specific anatomy
Brachycephalic Airway Syndrome (BAS) is categorised by a number of anatomical abnormalities due to redundant soft tissue that remains when the bony structure of the skull is reduced in size (Brown & Gregory, 2005). This can result in the excess tissue obstructing the upper airway, known as Brachycephalic Obstructive Airway Syndrome (BOAS).
There are primary and secondary anatomical abnormalities (Meola, 2013) that cause stridor, exercise intolerance, respiratory distress, cyanosis and collapse (Gruenheld et al., 2018). Primary anatomical abnormalities in BAS dogs include stenotic nares, elongated soft palate, nasopharyngeal turbinates and a hypoplastic trachea (Meola, 2013). Secondary abnormalities form due to the continued trauma of the pharyngeal soft tissue being pulled into the airway as a result of the primary conditions. It causes swelling, saccule eversion and laryngeal collapse (Meola, 2013), as seen in Figure 1. The anatomical abnormalities and their effects are listed in Table 1.
Figure 1. A normal airway compared to a collapsed airway of a BOAS dog.
Table 1. Brachycephalic anatomical abnormalities.
|Anatomy||Description||Physiological effects||Prevalence in BAS affected breeds|
|Stenotic nares||Narrow nostrils due to the collapse of the alae medially||The increase in airway resistance causes a greater pressure gradient to draw air in to lower airways resulting in the soft tissue structures being pulled caudally into the airway. Expiration is usually forced rather than being passive||46%|
|Elongated soft palate||The soft palate extends beyond the epiglottis||Causes obstruction and increasing airway resistance||Up to 100%|
|Nasopharyngeal turbinates||Abnormal turbinates extend caudally from the nasal cavities into the nasopharynx||Decrease the airflow through the nasal airway||21%, commonly seen in Pugs|
|Hypoplastic trachea||The tracheal cartilage is smaller and rigid. A hypoplastic trachea is defined as a tracheal diameter to tracheal inlet ratio (TD:TI) of <0.16 seen on a lateral radiograph (Thrall & Widmer, 2002) and is shown in Figure 2||A narrow larynx (due to soft tissue) can increase airway resistance by 16 times (Poiseuille’s Law) that of a non-brachycephalic breed. The increased negative pressure to overcome this resistance pulls soft tissue structures into the airway (Meola, 2013)||13%, commonly seen in Bulldogs and Boston Terriers|
|Everted saccules and tonsils||Saccules are located between the vocal and ventricular folds||More effort is required to overcome negative pressure to pull air into the lungs and results in turbulent airflow and vibration of the soft tissues, causing oedema and inversion. It is considered the first stage of laryngeal collapse (Pink, Doyle, Hughes, Tobin, & Bellenger, 2006)||46%|
|Laryngeal collapse||The laryngeal cartilage is under chronic stress and progressively loses it rigidity (Brown & Gregory, 2005)||The cuneiform is pulled into the rima glottis opening causing an increase in airway resistance and obstruction. The stages of laryngeal collapse are listed in Table 2||53%|
Table 2. The stages of laryngeal collapse.
|Stage I – eversion of laryngeal saccules Stage II – loss of rigidity and medial displacement of the cuneiform processes of the arytenoid cartilage Stage III – collapse of the corniculate processes of the arytenoid cartilage with loss of the dorsal arch of the rima glottis (Leonard, 1960)|
Figure 2. The TD:TI ratio in a brachycephalic and non-brachycephalic breed of the same weight.
Other specific brachycephalic anatomy and physiology considerations
Gastrointestinal complications include vomiting, regurgitation, ptyalism (Lodato & Hedlund, 2012), hiatal hernias (Callan et al., 1993) and pyloric stenosis (Peeters, 1991). The regurgitation may lead to aspiration pneumonia and a greater risk of respiratory fatigue (Shaver et al., 2017). Endoscopic and histologic changes were seen in 97% of a study group of brachycephalic dogs that had one or more upper respiratory tract abnormalities, where the most common finding was diffuse gastric inflammation (Poncet et al., 2005). One study showed that brachycephalic breeds of dogs have lower oesophageal pH (acidic) than non-brachycephalic dogs, and a high body condition score (BCS) significantly increases the severity of gastrointestinal findings (Aron & Crowe, 1985).
Dogs normally have three paranasal sinuses (lateral, rostral and medial frontal sinuses) which form the nasal passages; however, brachycephalic dogs are missing these (Brehm, Loeffler, & Komeyli, 1985), as shown in Figure 3.
Figure 3. Sinus size of a Pug compared to a Labrador.
Due to the shape of a brachycephalic skull, they may also be prone to globe proptosis because of the shallow orbit, so care should be taken during manual restraint (Severin, 1995). The skull shape should also be considered when performing an infraorbital nerve block to ensure globe penetration does not occur (Milella & Gurney, 2016).
Brachycephalic breeds may also suffer from a degree of facial nerve paralysis (Toombs & Hardy, 1981), and can have reduced palpebral reflexes due to fewer corneal sensory nerve fibres (Park et al., 2013). Constant lubrication and protection of the eyes should be performed.
English Bulldogs, Boxers and French Bulldogs have an increased occurrence of congenital cardiac abnormalities and acquired myocardial damage may also be seen in dogs with BAS (Oliveira et al., 2011). Brachycephalic breeds may have chronic hypoxia which causes hypoxic pulmonary vasoconstriction, leading to pulmonary hypertension and right-sided heart failure (Dugdale, 2011). They have high resting vagal tone making them prone to sinus bradycardia (Doxey and Boswood, 2004), sinus arrest and syncope, and second-degree atrioventricular block (Martin, 2015).
The admission process
Prior to anaesthesia, a full patient history should be obtained to determine the risk for individual patients (Miller & Gannon, 2015). It should encompass the signalment, medical history and the reason for anaesthesia. The fasting status should also be confirmed as prolonged fasting (>6 hours) increases the incidence for reflux and increased gastric acidity (Galatos & Raptopoulos, 1995). Feeding a small meal of wet food 3 hours prior to anaesthesia may reduce the incidence of gastroesophageal reflux (GOR) (Savvas, Rallis & Raptopoulos, 2009). Administering 1 mg/kg omeprazole 4 hours prior to anaesthesia may also reduce the incidence of GOR (Panti et al., 2009).
The owner should be asked if there has been any recent dysphagia, vomiting, or regurgitation which may identify a loss of physiological separation of swallowing and breathing mechanisms which increases risk for aspiration pneumonia (Miller & Gannon, 2015).
Assessing sleeping habits (sleep apnoea, choking, sleeping sitting upright) and exercise intolerance can be effective in evaluating BAS and the urgency of surgical intervention (Roedler, Pohl, & Oechtering, 2013).
The pre-anaesthetic physical exam
A basic assessment of the cardiovascular system is made by assessing the heart rate and rhythm, checking for pulse deficits and confirming the capillary refill time is adequate (Duncan, 2009). The heart should be auscultated for a minute on both sides of the chest to assess for murmurs (a low-grade murmur may be auscultated on one side and not the other).
The respiratory system is examined through auscultation of all lung fields (the cranial and caudal sections of both sides of the lungs (Lakelin, 2010) and by observing the depth, rhythm and rate of ventilation. If wheezes or crackles are auscultated this can be an indication of aspiration pneumonia secondary to regurgitation. If aspiration pneumonia is suspected, conscious thoracic radiographs should be taken to assess the severity. This may lead to the veterinary surgeon postponing the anaesthetic until the clinical signs have subsided (Posner, 2016). Pneumonia can be devastating for these breeds due to their hypoplastic trachea, decreased airway clearance and an increased risk of respiratory fatigue (Shaver et al., 2017). Any respiratory noise should be differentiated between pneumonia or Upper Respiratory Tract (URT) noise. True URT noise is mostly heard during inhalation and sounds louder when the stethoscope is placed on the trachea.
Pre-anaesthetic blood testing
Prior to a healthy patient undergoing anaesthesia, minimal database testing consisting of packed cell volume (PCV), blood glucose (BG), blood urea nitrogen (BUN) and alanine aminotransferase (ALT) should be performed (Tear, 2017). These can give an indication of hydration status, protein binding ability, plus assessment of kidney and liver function. Additional testing can be performed if the patient is systemically unwell prior to anaesthesia, or dependant on if other abnormalities are detected in the previous blood testing. An arterial blood gas analysis would be a beneficial guide to assessing pulmonary gaseous exchange (Dugdale, 2011); however, this type of testing may not be readily available.
Arterial blood gas analysis allows assessment of the patient’s partial pressure of oxygen and carbon dioxide (PaO2 and PaCO2). Hypoxaemia is defined as a PaO2 below 75 mmHg (normally 75–100 mmHg on room air) with hypercapnia defined as a PaCO2 above 42 mmHg (normally 38–42 mmHg). Brachycephalic breeds have a tendency towards a significantly higher PaCO2 and lower PaO2 than other breeds (Gruenheld et al., 2018).
Brachycephalic breeds can have a compensatory increase in haematocrit and haemoglobin due to the reduction in PaO2 (Wrzesinska, Klucinski, & Garncarz, 2017). This increase in PaCO2 can have significant effects on breathing. An increase in PaCO2 is detected by the chemoreceptors, which are located in the carotid body on each side of the carotid bifurcation, the aortic body and in the medulla, resulting in increased activity of the medullary respiratory centre (Frazer, 2009). This leads to diaphragm contraction, an increased respiratory rate and depth, and a subsequent increase in work of breathing (WOB). Increased WOB exacerbates the negative pressure within the airway, causing inward collapse of the airway.
CO2 in the body is converted to carbonic acid. This process releases hydrogen ions. Therefore, when PaCO2 increases, the production of hydrogen ions increases and so respiratory acidosis results. Increases in CO2 can also cause hyperkalaemia, decreased myocardial contractility and ventricular arrhythmias (Adshead, 2014). Therefore, if the level of hypoxaemia or hypercapnia is assessed prior to induction of anaesthesia, the veterinary team can prepare for its associated issues.
Body condition scoring (BCS)
An increase in BCS can lead to issues such as difficulty breathing, drug overdosing (versus dosing for the lean body weight) or drugs being injected into the fat rather than muscle, causing very slow distribution and effects. Some brachycephalic patients, such as pugs, can be difficult to BCS due to their skin folds. A breed-specific BCS has been developed for them, and is shown in Figure 4.
Figure 4. Breed-specific BCS for Pugs. Credit: Cambridge BOAS Research Group.
American Society of Anesthesiologists (ASA) physical status scale
This status is used to help the anaesthetist to determine the risk for each patient undergoing general anaesthesia. Brachycephalic breeds are generally classed as an ASA II due to their morphology (Gruenheld et al., 2018), causing mild systemic disease that does not limit their normal function. However, some brachycephalic patients are not able to compensate for the issues caused by their morphology and therefore their systemic disease could limit their normal function, classifying them as an ASA III, putting them at a moderate risk of mortality under anaesthetic. The ASA classifications are given in Table 3.
Table 3. ASA status adapted from Lysa P. Posner (2016), p. 6.
|ASA scale||Physical description||Veterinary patient examples|
|1||Normal patient with no disease||Healthy patient scheduled for spay or castration|
|2||Patient with mild systemic disease that does not limit normal function||Controlled diabetes mellitus, mild cardiac valve insufficiency|
|3||Patient with moderate systemic disease that limits normal function||Uncontrolled diabetes mellitus, symptomatic heart disease|
|4||Patient with severe systemic disease that is a constant threat to life||Sepsis, organ failure, heart failure|
|5||Patient that is moribund and not expected to live 24 hours without surgery||Shock, multiple organ failure, severe trauma|
|E||Describes patient as an emergency||Gastric dilatation–volvulus, respiratory distress|
This first article has shown the multifactoral considerations for brachycephalic breeds in the pre-anaesthesia period, and hopefully makes the veterinary team more informed to provide a tailored and safer pre-anaesthesia period.
Radiology Department of The Queen Mother Hospital for Animals for the MRI and radiograph images.
The Cambridge BOAS Research Group for the use of the Pug BSC Charts.
The support of the Anaesthesia Department of The Queen Mother Hospital for Animals.
Carol Hoy for the drawing of the airway.
Notes on contributors
Courtney Scales DipVN, NCert(Anaesth) RVNCourtney is originally from New Zealand, where she qualified as a Veterinary Nurse in 2010 and worked in a number of small animal clinics in Auckland. An anaesthesia passion took her to a large referral hospital in Australia in 2015. She has been working at the Royal Veterinary College since 2017. Email: firstname.lastname@example.org
Niamh J. Clancy
Niamh Clancy Dip AVN (Small Animal), DipHE, CVN, Dip VN, PGCert VetEd, FHEA, RVNNiamh graduated from University College Dublin with her Diploma in Veterinary Nursing in 2011. She then moved to the UK and worked in hospitals across London while studying for her Advanced Diploma, which she obtained from Myerscough College in 2015. She currently divides her time as an anaesthesia nurse at the Queen Mother Hospital for Animals and as a Clinical Educator in Anaesthesia for the veterinary nursing school at the Royal Veterinary College. She recently obtained her Certificate in Veterinary Education. Email: email@example.com